Private Prisons

Published: April 21, 2004

   At Issue:  The nation’s first faith-based prison for women opened in a Tampa-area detention center on April 14, a month after a similar program began for men. The prisons will be run with volunteers’ money, not the state’s. Do you find such a combination natural and useful? Is the combo something you expect to see more of elsewhere in the country, even California?
   Response:   With few programs currently available for rehabilitation, it is hard not to support alternatives for prisoners, especially if they may freely choose whether to participate.

  I know from experience that faith-based programs provided by volunteers at publicly funded prisons are worthwhile. The Zen Center of Orange County offered Zen and meditation programs at a penitentiary for three years. Many men, including those serving life sentences, eagerly welcomed resources for healing and growth. For those unlikely ever to be released, a spiritual path offered a means of living fully under any conditions, and facing a future holding only more years of prison. For those who would be released, programs on anger management, impulse control, and addiction were well attended by men desperate to find the key to avoid return to prison. Yet lockdowns, lack of meeting rooms, staff shortages and various scheduling problems seriously interfered with the volunteer program.

 In India, the former Inspector of Prisons introduced meditation training, retreats and residential programs at India’s largest prison.  The amazing transformation of inmates is documented in a 1997 film, “Doing Time, Doing Vipassana.”  Due to security
  concerns, it can be impossible to have meditation cushions, retreat days, a somewhat quiet spot, or meaningful support in offering this kind of program.  Our group sat on folded army blankets and we considered ourselves lucky to have them.  Whether from the public, as in India, or from private sources, programs offering opportunities for faith-based transformation should be supported.         

       I would hope that faith-based prisons would reflect the religious diversity of our culture, and that a broad range of choices would exist.  Nonetheless, I think it is an illusion to believe that private volunteer groups can fill a job of this magnitude, and one which is our public responsibility.  It is hard to imagine how prisoners will change their lives in prisons if there is not adequate funding for ongoing therapy, treatment for addictions of all kinds and a decent chance at rehabilitation—for the good of men and women in prison and for the good of us all.

   - Rev. Dr. Deborah Barrett